D1Baseball names Dempsey First Team All-American
FORT MYERS, Fla. – Florida Gulf Coast University's Evan Dempsey has been named a 2025 First Team All-American by D1Baseball, the site announced Thursday. Dempsey is one of just 15 players nationwide to earn Consensus All-American status, having received First Team honors from four of the six major organizations that bestow the title.
In addition to D1Baseball, Dempsey earned First Team All-American recognition from Perfect Game, the College Baseball Foundation and Baseball America. He surpasses FGCU legend Chris Sale, who earned three First Team honors during his historic 2010 season.
Dempsey also received the John Olerud Award, presented by the College Baseball Foundation to the nation's top two-way player. He was named National 2-Way Player of the Year by Perfect Game and earned First Team All-American honors as a two-way player from Baseball America. Both D1Baseball and the College Baseball Foundation recognized him as a First Team utility player. He was also named a Second Team All-American by the American Baseball Coaches Association.
On the mound, Dempsey went 5-1 with a 1.97 ERA in 15 appearances, including 10 starts. The sophomore logged 68.2 innings, striking out 75 and walking 20. Of the 57 hits he allowed, only six went for extra bases. Opponents batted just .225 against him. In his final start of the season, on four days' rest, Dempsey pitched five innings to lead FGCU to a 6-5 win over Stetson, clinching a share of the Atlantic Sun Conference championship.
As an outfielder, the Tampa native played in all 60 games, starting 59. He batted .309 with 71 hits, including 18 doubles and three home runs, for a .435 slugging percentage. He scored 41 runs, drove in 30 and was a perfect 14-for-14 on stolen base attempts, tying for the team lead.
Defensively, Dempsey committed just one error in 99 chances, recording 86 putouts and 12 assists—including two from the outfield—for a .990 fielding percentage
2025 Consensus All-Americans
Evan Dempsey – FGCU (P/OF/UT)
Kade Anderson – LSU (P)
Jamie Arnold – Florida State (P)
Liam Doyle – Tennessee (P)
Jake Knapp – North Carolina (P)
Jacob Morrison – Coastal Carolina (P)
Kyson Witherspoon – Oklahoma (P)
Dylan Volantis – Texas (P)
Andrew Fischer – Tennessee (1B)
Roch Cholowski – UCLA (SS)
Alex Lodise – Florida State (SS/DH)
Daniel Cuvet – Miami (3B)
Drew Burress – Georgia Tech (OF)
Ike Irish – Auburn (OF)
James Quinn-Irons – George Mason (OF)
Players Mentioned
Players Mentioned
Latest Baseball
- Henschel selected in 2025 MLB DraftFORT MYERS, Fla. – Right-handed pitcher Justin Henschel was selected in the 2025 Major League Baseball draft. Henschel came off the board in the seventh round, picked by the Cincinnati Reds on Monday afternoon.
- Dempsey earns 2025 All-American status from College Baseball FoundationFORT MYERS, Fla. - Already the winner of the John Olerud Award as the nation's best two-way player by the College Baseball Foundation, Florida Gulf Coast University's Evan Dempsey earned another honor from the organization Wednesday as he was named to the 2025 All-America Team.
- Dempsey named First Team All-American by Baseball AmericaFORT MYERS, Fla. – Florida Gulf Coast University standout Evan Dempsey added another accolade to his growing list Friday, as Baseball America named the Tampa native a First Team All-American.
- Dempsey earns USA Baseball Collegiate Team inviteFORT MYERS, Fla. — The 2025 John Olerud Two-Way Player of the Year will don the Stars and Stripes this summer, as Florida Gulf Coast University's Evan Dempsey has been invited to compete at the USA Baseball Collegiate National Team Training Camp in late June.
- Red, White and (Green and) Blue: FGCU’s Tollett to Coach for USA Baseball Collegiate TeamFORT MYERS, Fla. – Florida Gulf Coast University head baseball coach Dave Tollett has been named to the coaching staff for the 2025 USA Baseball Collegiate National Team, USA Baseball announced Monday afternoon.
- Dempsey wins Olerud Award for National Two-Way Player of the YearFORT MYERS, Fla. - Florida Gulf Coast University's Evan Dempsey has been named the 2025 John Olerud National Two-Way Player of the Year as announced by the College Baseball Foundation Friday morning in Overland Park, Kansas.